Popular Items
Matzo Ball Soup
4.99
TooJay's Shepherd's Pie
13.99
Reuben
13.59
Mini Potato Pancakes
7.79
Chicken Noodle Soup
4.79
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
12.59
TooJay's Cobb Salad
12.79
Turkey Breast Sandwich
11.59
Traditional Turkey Dinner
15.99
Dippin' Chicken'
5.79
Seasonal Menu - Limited Time Offer
Philly Grilled Cheese
11.99
Chocolate Cheese Delight
6.99
Starters
Loaded Latkes
10.99
Beer Battered Onion Rings
6.99
Mini Potato Pancakes
7.79
Cheese Blintzes
8.79
Fried Dill Pickles
6.79
TooJay's Famous Knish
4.79
Nova Latkes*
8.99
Chopped Liver
6.99
Soups
Matzo Ball Soup
4.99
Chicken Noodle Soup
4.79
Deli Classics From The Deli
Triple J*
12.59
TooJay's Classic
12.59
Combo Deli Platter
12.99
Deli Classics From The Kitchen
Reuben
13.59
Turkey Reuben
13.59
Rachel
13.59
Beef Brisket Dip
13.79
Deli Sandwiches
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
12.59
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
12.59
Turkey Breast Sandwich
11.59
Turkey Avocado Sandwich
12.99
Roast Beef Sandwich*
11.99
Beef Brisket Sandwich
12.59
Liverwurst Sandwich
9.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
9.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
10.79
Tongue Sandwich
14.59
Hummus Wrap
9.99
Nova on a Bagel*
13.99
Hand Tossed Salads
Chicken Caesar Salad
11.59
Crispy Chicken Salad
11.79
Greek Salad
10.99
TooJay's Chopped Salad
12.79
TooJay's Cobb Salad
12.79
Strawberry Citrus Salad
10.99
Deli Salads
Dill Chicken Salad Sandwich
9.99
Dill Chicken Salad Platter
9.99
Traditional Chicken Salad Sandwich
9.99
Traditional Chicken Salad Platter
9.99
Stuffed Tomato
10.99
Tuna Salad Sandwich
11.59
Tuna Salad Platter
11.59
T.J.‘S Trio Salad Platter
12.79
Egg Salad Platter
8.99
Egg Salad Sandwich
8.99
Choose Too
Cup Of Soup + House or Caesar Salad
8.99
Cup Of Soup + Scoop Of Deli Salad
10.79
Cup Of Soup + Café-Sized Hand Tossed Salad
10.99
Cup Of Soup + Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich
10.79
Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich + House or Caesar Salad
9.79
Hot Handhelds
Philly Grilled Cheese (Limited Time Only)
11.99
Chicken Tenders
10.99
Avocado BLT
10.99
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
8.99
Grilled Cheese
8.99
Fish & Chips
11.99
Open Faced Turkey Melt
12.99
Open Faced Tuna Melt
12.99
Deli Dogs
8.99
Burgers & Chicken
Burger á la TooJay's*
12.79
Patty Melt*
10.99
Turkey Burger Patty Melt
10.99
Black Bean Patty Melt
10.99
Pastrami Burger*
14.79
Chicken á la TooJay's
12.79
Chipotle Bacon Burger
12.79
Build Your Own Beef Burger
10.5
Build Your Own Turkey Burger
10.5
Build Your Own Black Bean Burger
10.5
Build Your Own Grilled Chicken Sandwich
10.5
Classic Comforts
TooJay's Shepherd's Pie
13.99
Liver and Onions*
14.79
Beef Brisket Platter
17.79
Black and Bleu Chopped Sirloin Bowl
16.79
Traditional Turkey Dinner
15.99
Fish & Chips Dinner
16.79
Grilled Chopped Sirloin*
15.99
Desserts
Chocolate Layer Cake
6.99
3 Mini Black & Whites
2.79
Mini Napoleon & Éclair Combo (2)
4.79
Mini Napoleon & Éclair Combo (4)
7.99
Brownie
3.79
Tollhouse Square
3.79
Rugalach (3)
2.99
Banana Dream
6.99
Carrot Cake
6.99
Plain Cheesecake Slice
6.99
Cheesecake with Strawberries
7.59
Coconut Cake
6.99
Key Lime Pie
4.99
Killer Cake Slice
6.99
Combo Dessert For Too
11.99
Macaroons (3)
2.79
Cheese Blintzes
8.79
Beverages
Cranberry Juice - Pint
2.99
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
2.99
Florida Orange Juice
2.99
Martinelli's Apple Juice
2.99
Milk
2.99
TooJay's Bottled Water
2.79
Arnold Palmer
2.99
Strawberry Lemonade
3.59
Lemonade
2.99
Fountain Soda
2.99
Peach Iced Tea
3.59
Egg Cream
2.99
Fresh Brewed Coffee
2.79
Gourmet Hot Tea
2.99
Assorted Fruit Juices
2.99
Canned Beverages
Diet Pepsi
1.99
Pepsi
1.99
Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
2.99
Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
2.99
Dr. Brown's Celray
2.99
Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry
2.99
Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
2.99
Dr. Brown's Ginger Ale
2.99
Dr. Brown's Root Beer
2.99
Kid's Menu
Grilled Cheese
4.79
Hamburger
5.79
Cheeseburger
5.79
Chicken Salad Chop Chop
5.79
Dippin' Chicken'
5.79
Jr. Tuna Melt
5.79
Mac n' Cheese
5.79
Deli Dog
4.79
Kid's Fountain Beverage
1.99
Kid's Lemonade
1.99
Kid's Milk
1.99
Kid's Chocolate Milk
1.99
Deli Meat
1/2 lbs. Brisket
10.99
1 lbs. Brisket
21.98
1/2 lbs. Corned Beef
9.49
1 lbs. Corned Beef
18.98
1/2 lbs. Ham
5.99
1 lbs. Ham
11.98
1/2 lbs. Liverwurst
4.99
1 lbs. Liverwurst
9.98
1/2 lbs. Pastrami
9.49
1 lbs. Pastrami
18.98
1/2 lbs. Roast Beef
8.49
1 lbs. Roast Beef
16.98
1/2 lbs. Turkey
7.49
1 lbs. Turkey
14.98
1/2 lbs. Turkey Pastrami
7.49
1 lbs. Turkey Pastrami
14.98
1/2 lbs. Tongue
11.49
1 lbs. Tongue
22.98
1/2 lbs. Chopped Liver
6.49
1 lbs. Chopped Liver
12.98
Deli Cheese
1/2 lbs. American Cheese
3.99
1 lbs. American Cheese
7.98
1/2 lbs. Muenster Cheese
4.49
1 lbs. Muenster Cheese
8.98
1/2 lbs. Provolone Cheese
4.49
1 lbs. Provolone Cheese
8.98
1/2 lbs. Swiss Cheese
4.49
1 lbs. Swiss Cheeese
8.98
Deli Fish
1/2 lbs. Nova Sliced
20.49
1 lbs. Nova Sliced
40.98
1 lb. Whitefish Chunk
19.98
1/2 lb. Whitefish Chunk
9.99
Deli Bread
(6) Half Dozen Bagels
6.99
(12) Dozen Bagels
11.99
Challah Loaf
4.49
Rye Half Loaf
4.29
Rye Full Loaf
8.58
Deli Salad
1/2 lbs. Cole Slaw
2.79
1 lbs. Cole Slaw
5.58
1/2 lbs. Dill Chicken Salad
6.99
1 lbs. Dill Chicken Salad
13.98
1/2 lbs. Egg Salad
5.49
1 lbs. Egg Salad
10.98
1/2 lbs. Potato Salad
2.79
1 lbs. Potato Salad
5.58
1/2 lbs. Traditional Chicken Salad
6.99
1 lbs. Traditional Chicken Salad
13.98
1/2 lbs. Tuna Salad
7.49
1 lbs. Tuna Salad
14.98
1/2 lbs. Fruit Salad
5.49
1 lbs. Fruit Salad
10.98
Whole Cakes
Chocolate Cheese Delight (Limited Time Only)
25.99
Coconut Cake
25.99
Cheesecake
25.99
Banana Dream
25.99
Carrot Cake
25.99
Chocolate Layer
25.99
Key Lime Pie
16.99
Killer Cake
25.99
